Karlyn,
Since you said you switched to Proof, you might have already read the following Adobe tech doc –
<
http://www.adobe.com/support/techdocs/330847.html>
But if not, I suggest that you read it.
The short answer is that for a better quality slideshow with music and transitions to play on a TV, a DVD burner is an appropriate investment.
Additionally, the techdoc says that you can burn higher quality VCDs in the Photoshop Album product. That is true but one fact not stated in this techdoc is that the higher resolution photo VCD can not include music.
Based on my experience and other posts that I have read your odds of getting the quality you want on a VCD are not good. You have already tried Solution 2 in the techdoc by using Proof. The only other thought is to downsize a copy of the photos to 800×600 in the Elements Editor before starting the Slideshow creation. The odds of this being sufficient to solve the problem are not great, so I would try it on 1 or 2 photos first.
Based on reading the Organizer Your Photos with Elements 3 book (see <
http://photofanatic.com/> for more info on the book), you will only see Burn to DVD in the PS Elements 3 drop down box if you also have the Adobe Premiere Elements product installed. Photoshop Elements will not burn a Custom Slideshow to a DVD.
Solutions that people have used are:
(you might search the forum for direct comments from other people)
– save the Elements 3 custom slideshow at best quality WMV (800×600 Proof), then use the DVD burning software that came with their DVD burner to create (author) the DVD. This produces quality better than the E 3 VCD, but not as good as directly creating a slideshow and then burning to DVD (because of the intermediate step of making the compressed format WMV file).
– solution 1 from the tech doc (If you have Premiere Elements and a DVD burner, send the images from Photoshop Elements to Premiere Elements and burn a DVD). However, note that Premiere Elements is primarily a video editing program, so purchasing it for the purpose of doing slideshows is somewhat questionable.
– purchase a separate slideshow program for your slideshows. Ignore the slideshow functions of Elements. Enjoy the Editing and Organization functions of Elements, while using a different program specifically designed for slideshows.
One additional possibility that does not have all the artistic creativity of creating a Slideshow is to use a TV DVD player that can display JPEG images from a CD as the means of displaying your photos on TV. Some of the TV DVD players will also support music, but it is nothing fancy and there is probably no choice of transitions. Photo quality should be better than VCDs.
Well, that was a long response. Since there was not a simple answer to your question, I attempted to lay out the alternatives. I suspect that if I missed something, another person will post with their comments.
Barb O