Views
1097
Replies
12
Status
Closed
Photoshop: 6
Hardware: Nikon LS-50
Software: NikonScan 4.02
Taking a well deserved (!) break from Kodachromes I started playing with B&W negatives today (Ilford, if anyone is curious). I wonder what the panel thinks of the less "sensible" of the possible scanning permutations for B&W negatives:
1. Mono Neg/Grayscale – boooriiing… ;o)
2. Mono Neg/RGB
3. Color Neg/Grayscale
4. Color Neg/RGB
5. Color Pos/Grayscale
6. Color Pos/RGB
For example, scanning B&W negatives as Mono Neg/RGB has obvious advantages because some blemishes are much more easily corrected with access to 3 individual RGB channels, converting to grayscale only as the last step.
I wonder if there are any similar advantages to some of the other permutations specifically in terms of, say, dynamic range or sharpness, etc.
For example, at first blush, taking an individual channel from an RGB scan seems sharper than a grayscale scan which, presumably, started life as a composite (all 3 LEDs on).
Another example is that fine scratches appear easier to spot if scanning as Positive and then inverting as the last step, etc.
Don.
Hardware: Nikon LS-50
Software: NikonScan 4.02
Taking a well deserved (!) break from Kodachromes I started playing with B&W negatives today (Ilford, if anyone is curious). I wonder what the panel thinks of the less "sensible" of the possible scanning permutations for B&W negatives:
1. Mono Neg/Grayscale – boooriiing… ;o)
2. Mono Neg/RGB
3. Color Neg/Grayscale
4. Color Neg/RGB
5. Color Pos/Grayscale
6. Color Pos/RGB
For example, scanning B&W negatives as Mono Neg/RGB has obvious advantages because some blemishes are much more easily corrected with access to 3 individual RGB channels, converting to grayscale only as the last step.
I wonder if there are any similar advantages to some of the other permutations specifically in terms of, say, dynamic range or sharpness, etc.
For example, at first blush, taking an individual channel from an RGB scan seems sharper than a grayscale scan which, presumably, started life as a composite (all 3 LEDs on).
Another example is that fine scratches appear easier to spot if scanning as Positive and then inverting as the last step, etc.
Don.
Related Tags
How to Improve Photoshop Performance
Learn how to optimize Photoshop for maximum speed, troubleshoot common issues, and keep your projects organized so that you can work faster than ever before!