Unless your monitor is totally screwed it should be close enough to sRGB that differences in colours between the two apps will be minimal.
There’s something I don’t quite understand here.
I thought that sRGB was like a common denominator that tries to describe the common monitor around the world, but that doesn’t mean that the gamut of every monitor in the world is so close to sRGB, that you’ll never see inconsistency between sRGB and Monitor-RGB, does it?
If that’s the case, then I’m getting paranoid over the accuracy of my monitor profiles made with a Spyder from ColorVision and OptiCAL software, because my two monitor profiles is pretty far from sRGB.
This is my monitor profiles compared to sRGB:
<
http://home18.inet.tele.dk/madsen/monitor/colour>. (The TFT is a Viewsonic VP201s and the CRT is a Sony GDM-FW900).
A blue colour for instance, defined as R:0, G:0, B:255 in an sRGB document, doesn’t look the same in Photoshop and ImageReady here, and especially not on my TFT. I was sure that the reason for this inconsistency was that ImageReady always sends the numbers directly to the monitor (and therefore always uses Monitor-RGB) because it isn’t colour managed.
Photoshop on the other hand, is colour managed and corrects the colours that it sends to the monitor so that the sRGB profile is "honoured", if sRGB is embedded in the document (or if sRGB is chosen as the working space and you open a document untagged). After reading this thread, I’m suddenly in doubt.
A document tagged with sRGB and filled with R:0, G:0, B:255 in Photoshop, has a much more saturated blue when viewed in ImageReady than it has in Photoshop but right now I can’t figure out why, when I look at: <
http://home18.inet.tele.dk/madsen/monitor/colour>. As I see it, sRGB should give me at more saturated blue than my TFT monitor profile can give me, because the gamut of sRGB goes farther into the blues than my TFT profile does, but what I see in Photoshop and ImageReady, is the complete opposite of that. I’m confused and not just a little. Maybe I should go to bed and sleep on it, because it has bugged me for the last couple of hours.
—
Regards
Madsen.