exported JPG vs. save for the web JPG

295 views7 repliesLast post: 2/7/2007
Hi there-
I have OS10.4.8 and Photoshop 7.0. I create files that end up being shared with various PC users-- for proofing a document, for instance. These PC users can not view or open files that I export as JPGs from photoshop, but they can view JPGs that have been saved for the web.

The problem is that the exported JPGs are at the high resolutions that I need, and the webJPGs are not. what's going on with the exported JPGs? I thought one factor might be the emailing, however the exported JPGs don't work when I ftp them to a public folder for downloading.

any advice will be appreciated--
Lisa
#1
Do you include the 3 letter extension?

are your saved Jpgs CMYK?

SFW will by default save an RGB file
#2
do include .jpg

they are in CMYK mode

these particular images are grayscale, so maybe I'll switch to that mode.

so- should I include the extension (and why are PCs still having extension problems???) and which mode is best for color images?

thanks for your quick response!
#3
Depends on what they are using to view the files and perhaps the method of transfer (though FTPed files should not be a problem). I have no trouble whatsoever opening CMYK jpegs in Photoshop on my Windows computer. I have often moved files from the Mac to PC without a hitch.

Make sure the recipients have appropriate software or make the files RGB.
#5
Some windows viewers can't read CMYK files
#6
thanks-- all these good suggestions apply, and even seem to be working already-- but it does seem that is also depends on the user at the other end. too many variables, and unfortunately the people I work with know even less about their computers than I do.
but all this helped a lot.
#7
Just so you know... when you save a jpg using "save as for web" it automatically converts it to RGB. When you save a JPG normally it does not. My guess is that your PC friends are having an issue with the CMYK format. Which is common among non-graphic people. Not just PC people. Although on a Mac 'Preview' opens just about all of the formats...

So... before sending out the proof - convert to RGB and then do a normal save in JPG format. But keep your CMYK file for production.

cheers!
Jeff
#8