SpaceGirl ha scritto:
Gary wrote:
As part of the testing team, I'm sure glad that I didn't get fired.
:D
If you'd be working for me, you would have LOL
Installation problems did happen by the time the software shipped, and a public beta was activated on December 15th of 2006, and although a few (less
than 1/2 of 1%) of installation events did encounter a problem, it was cut
to a tenth of that before ship date.
All of our issues had nothing to do with the beta. We NEVER install beta software on production machines. It was mostly down two conflicts with the Flash player ("compontent failed to install") and other DLLs, and antivirus. None of this was resolved by Adobe I must add... we spent about a week getting it to work, which required removing of registry entries etc. Now we have some pretty wired technical people in our studio, so we got around it eventually. I would have been seriously pissed if I spent £1000 + on software only to hit the wall of denial we got from the official support at Adobe, and then having to hack my own computer to get the thing to work. If this had been one machine, or even two I'd have put it down to Windows being crap. But this happened on all but 4 of the 30 machines we ran installs on. Each machine had differing configuration, some different Windows versions. Even the AV we're using isn't the same on all machines. The only common thing between the machines... was the Adobe installer (Creative Suite 3 Web Edition)
That is no excuse for your having problems -- and no attempt at all on my part to diminish the problems (or the costs associated with those problems).
I've been in the graphic arts industry longer than Adobe (and email, for that matter) and troubles associated with the kind of highly integrated environments that these technologies have generated brings with it a combination of horrific days and days where we get work done that fifteen years ago would have taken twelve times as long using twelve employees instead of two.
That IS no excuse. The products themselves work (IMO) flawlessly. The installer was a nightmare. Bit pointless putting all that effort into wonderful things in PSCS3 (which, I cannot live without now) if you can't even get it to unpack from DVD in the first place! Whoever was responsible for the building of the installers really let down the rest of the hard working Adobe team - the rest of the product is fantastic!
You can certainly contact me directly () and I
would be
more than happy to work with you and try to figure out what the problem is.
Doing that can not only help you feel better about Adobe but would help me
a) avoid the same exact thing happening at some time in our environment and
b) tell others how to avoid it.
Well we fixed our issues, eventually.
But don't be mad at Adobe. They're not bad people. And there is no testing
'department'. Roughly 2000 people wordl wide are chosen as outside testers
who represented a wide stroke of markets and environments.
Personally I'm VERY mad at Adobe, but also in Love. CS3 has changed the way I work, forever, and for the better. I could never go back. But at the same time I feel really let down. Fantastic products let down by what should have been one of the more simpler parts of the suite... the installer. I'm hardly alone in this... 2 minutes googling will bring back 1000s of reports of issues with the installer. Whatever real world testing was done for installing was clearly hopelessly inadequate.
By time the software shipped, there were about 100 left. The drop off happens for a number of reasons, not the least of which is failure to work
at making Adobe products work. And they do.
No software is perfect. That's not the issue really. Adobe was very slow to react when issues started being reported and... come on... 40 minutes to install a bit of software? That's just crazy. You can install the whole of Windows in less time. Now try doing that install 6 times in one day because the installer fails every time...
I'm very glad I use Macs at my home studio! 20 minutes install, no problems at all.
And we don't get paid (I take that back -- I have a signed box with the Creative Suite in it. We also paid for two dozen licenses worldwide for employees, too).
Gary poyssick in tampa, florida and staunch defender of Adobe. Would you trade an easier installation for a camera and type lead? I don't think so :-)
No, but I won't let any of my clients or studios upgrade to CS4. Not until the next round of upgrades are proven, no matter how good they are. I'm not going through that headache again!
"I hate and (yet) I love" (in Latin, Odi et amo) was written by the Roman poet Catullus for his mistress Lesbia
:)
Jokes apart...
I've tried to install PSCS3 without the firewall and without the anti-virus. I've erased any possible reference about Adobe in any folder and in any register-key. The only thing I can do now is a low level format of HDD or erase the hidden info Adobe written on my HDD (but I don't know where). Nevertheless I think the problem is on a missed path value. Here follow a part of 2 logs, the first generated from the installer on my PC (failed), the second one generated from the installer on another PC (win XP pro like mine) (success)
wrong
=====
(Adobe) -*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*- BEGIN - Adobe_InstallALMService -*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-
(Adobe) Requesting property: CustomActionData
(Adobe) Value
00000003000000020000000100000004Name00000020ALMInstallLibFil eKey0000000100000005Value00000000000000020000000100000004Nam e00000009AdobeCode0000000100000005Value00000038{2E4528EC-5AC B-4D19-98DD-6CC3594EB1A1}000000020000000100000004Name0000001 9LanguageIndependent0000000100000005Value000000011
(Adobe) Allocating istringstream:
(Adobe) Stream extraction to recordset
(Adobe) Number of Properties: 3
(Adobe) Name, Value: ALMInstallLibFileKey
(Adobe) Name, Value: AdobeCode {2E4528EC-5ACB-4D19-98DD-6CC3594EB1A1} (Adobe) Name, Value: LanguageIndependent 1
(Adobe) ALM language: ALL
(Adobe) Path to ALM installer library:
(Adobe) Path does not exist
(Adobe) #_AdobeError_# 1603
(Adobe) -*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*- END - Adobe_InstallALMService -*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-
right
=====
(Adobe) -*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*- BEGIN - Adobe_InstallALMService -*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-
(Adobe) Requesting property: CustomActionData
(Adobe) Value
00000003000000020000000100000004Name00000020ALMInstallLibFil eKey0000000100000005Value00000081C:\Programmi\File
comuni\Adobe\Adobe Anchor
Service\adobelm_service_installer.dll00000002000000010000000 4Name00000009AdobeCode0000000100000005Value00000038{2E4528EC -5ACB-4D19-98DD-6CC3594EB1A1}000000020000000100000004Name000 00019LanguageIndependent0000000100000005Value000000011
(Adobe) Allocating istringstream:
(Adobe) Stream extraction to recordset
(Adobe) Number of Properties: 3
(Adobe) Name, Value: ALMInstallLibFileKey C:\Programmi\File comuni\Adobe\Adobe Anchor Service\adobelm_service_installer.dll (Adobe) Name, Value: AdobeCode {2E4528EC-5ACB-4D19-98DD-6CC3594EB1A1} (Adobe) Name, Value: LanguageIndependent 1
(Adobe) ALM language: ALL
(Adobe) Path to ALM installer library: C:\Programmi\File comuni\Adobe\Adobe Anchor Service\adobelm_service_installer.dll (Adobe) AdobeCode: {2E4528EC-5ACB-4D19-98DD-6CC3594EB1A1} Language: ALL Mode: 1
(Adobe) Installing ALM...
[ 2116] Tue Jul 31 10:35:16 2007 INFO
(Adobe) ALM return code: 0
(Adobe) -*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*- END - Adobe_InstallALMService -*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-*-
as you can see the path value "C:\Programmi\File comuni\Adobe\Adobe Anchor Service\adobelm_service_installer.dll" is missing on the "ALMInstallLibFileKey " variable.
I looked for this value on *.xml files of the installation package but nothing... :(